Powered by Bravenet Bravenet Blog

Subscribe to Journal

Sunday, September 6th 2009

6:59 AM

Variations in Shaping

I’d like to be able to say I’m well acquainted with all the shapes available for bassoon reeds as well as the unique features and benefits of them all but the truth is I have not experimented with that many different shapes.  But, I have learned that there are a good many variations that can be made just from one bassoon cane shaper. 

In my business I use a facsimile of the Fox #2 and Rieger 1A shapes.  That is, along with the automatic shaper I bought from Reedsn’stuff, I have templates that make the two shapes.  However, if I place my wires at different points on the reed and the overall length changes then the reed’s shape changes also, especially the width at the tip.  I use the Fox #2 for my own reeds because of the following reasons:

1) The width at the butt allows me to assemble the reed and fit it to the bocal without reaming the reed.

2) The throat is large enough for the amount of resistance I desire.  This would not be the case if I made the tube smaller and then reamed the reed.

3) The blades are practically straight, with a slight amount of concave curve near the shoulder.  Some other shapers produce a convex shape, often called a "wine glass" shape.

4) The medium shape gives me the control I desire in the high register while maintaining a resonant low register.

With the Rieger 1a shape I find that for my own use I often have to narrow the reed or even cut the blade 1 mm shorter to get the ease of response in the highest register.

Many of my students have wanted to experiment with different shapes before they refine their finishing techniques.  Generally, I discourage this.  I believe that a student will see a more dramatic improvement in their reed’s performance as they learn to implement proper finish techniques.  Also, many of these techniques require a good bit of practice and repetition in order to perfect them.

The Knochenhauer shape was the first shape I used when I learned to make reeds.  I found that the curve through the throat area was deeper and the change of direction more abrupt than it is in the Fox shaper, which  made it harder to shape without developing splits either up the blade or towards the butt.  I never found the sound I was looking for with that shaper and I think it may have been with the size of the throat resulting from that dramatic and rather narrow shape.

The rather well-known Herzberg Shaper has a flare at the butt end that allowed him to bevel all four edges of the cane and not narrow his tube too much.  On my reeds I place a 30 degree bevel on opposite sides from just inside the first wire to the butt of the reed, starting shallow and  getting a little deeper as I approach the butt.  My bevel is not intended to narrow the bark surface, only the inside of the cane.

There are two ways to make a reed more resistance and raise the pitch by removing cane.  One is to cut the tip and the other is to file the sides of reed, narrowing the shape.  When I file the sides of my reed I use a diamond file that is more than 1/8” thick and very sturdy, much more so than a nail file.  Some players narrow different areas on the sides of the blades to control pitch in different registers of the bassoon.

To summarize about the quality of wider versus narrow shapes, wider shapes have a larger air chamber and potentially larger sound, bigger low register with better response, lower pitch (that can be mitigated with thicker and shorter blades), and less easily controlled.  Smaller shapes have more focus, generally higher pitch, ease of response in high register and can be made with a thinner profile.  Of course, going back to the gouge we can control some of the factors mentioned above by changing the gouge.

If you are looking for a particular shape used and designed by a well-known player you should check out the Fox Products website as they carry several of these shapes in the flat shaper style.  I use a flat shaper rather than a fold-over partly because I use an automatic shaper.  Fold-over shapers work well but you have to be able to hold the knife perfectly perpendicular to the shaper in order to get perfectly shaped cane.  The flat shaper I use removes the possibilities of uneven or unsymmetrical cuts. 

I like to shape before I profile.  Because of guide lines I have machined into my profilers I have no problem lining up cane so the spine is cut into the center of the cane.

I’m sure there are many other ideas on shaping and I welcome any and all comments.



30 Comment(s).

Posted by Robert Smith:

Posted by Robert Smith:

Get the solutions to all the technical issues with all your electronic appliances at Geek Squad Tech Support. Avail wide no of services, on-site, and over the Internet via remote access and In-store, and also provides 24/7 telephone and emergency on-site support. Reach the experts at Geek Squad Tech Support for removing all technical glitches with your devices
Wednesday, August 7th 2019 @ 12:28 AM

Posted by Robert Smith:

Geek Squad Tech Support provides the best technical help and guidance. Get in touch with extensively trained tech support team for all sort of queries and issues regarding your devices. You can contact Geek Squad round the clock according to your convenience.
Wednesday, August 7th 2019 @ 12:25 AM

Posted by http://ligatamora.net/:

ligatamora merupakan situs judi online terbaik dan terpercaya di Indonesia pada tahun 2019 ini.
Tuesday, August 6th 2019 @ 9:28 AM

Posted by geek squad:

Geek Squad Protection goes above and beyond the manufacturer's warranty to extend your coverage and protect your purchase. geek squad chat
Tuesday, July 23rd 2019 @ 4:24 PM

Posted by sam:

This was a shocking post. It has some look at here fundamental data on this subject. 프로미 먹튀
Monday, July 22nd 2019 @ 6:18 AM

Posted by Lapak Judi Bola:

Good article and have a nice content, really enjoy it. thanks for sharing.
Visit our site on :

Lapak Judi Bola
Liga 88
Jasa Bola
Friday, June 14th 2019 @ 11:40 PM

Posted by norton.com/setup:

Norton support every operating system including Windows. You can get your Norton security from the retail store or can get it from online as well.mcafee.com/activate | office.com/setup
Thursday, June 13th 2019 @ 5:40 AM

Posted by Schließen der Katzenklappe:

Die Katzenklappe isoliert gilt unter Katzenfreunden als ganz besonders wetterbeständig und daher gut geeignet, auch zum Einbau in Außentüren oder in Fenster, die beständig einem rauen Klima und den besonders schwerwiegenden negativen Einflüssen des Wetters ausgesetzt sind. Um diese Erwartungen dann letztendlich auch in der Praxis gut erfüllen zu können, ist eine solche Katzenklappe isoliert heute aus besonders hochwertigen Materialien https://katzenklappe-chip.wixsite.com/mysite/post/katzenklappe gefertigt worden, die dann auch Wind und Sturm, Schnee, Regen und Hagel, über einen vergleichsweise langen Zeitraum hinweg erfolgreich zu trotzen vermögen. Die bewährte und begehrte isolierte Katzenklappe gibt es überdies heute in praktisch schon jedem Baumarkt, in der Zoofachhandlung oder alternativ zu diesen genannten Einkaufsmöglichkeiten dann natürlich auch bei den einschlägig bekannten Spezial- oder auch Universalversendern im Internet zu kaufen.
Saturday, May 11th 2019 @ 8:09 AM

Posted by kontraktor pameran:

Great post and success for you..

Kontraktor Pameran
Jasa Pembuatan Booth Pameran
Kontraktor Booth Pameran
Jasa Pembuatan Booth
Saturday, April 6th 2019 @ 9:15 PM

Posted by Seoger: Bandar Togel Online Terpercaya, Bocoran Togel Akurat hanya di Togel Pedia salah satu situs togel terbaik, apabila anda ingin mencari situs untuk memasang angka, maka anda tidak salah tempat, disinilah anda bisa menanamkan modal anda dan melipat gandakan modal anda
Saturday, March 9th 2019 @ 8:17 AM

Posted by Sue:

Posted by Bandung:

Outbound Bandung - Outbound Gathering Bandung adalah perusahaan yang berdomisili di Bandung dan bergerak dibidang pelatihan sumber daya manusia terutama di alam terbuka dengan menggunakan alam sebagai medianya serta kami juga Penyedia Jasa/Provider Outbound, untuk kegiatan – kegiatan yang sifatnya menantang dan petualangan ( Adventure ) seperti : Highrope ( Spider Web, Two Line Bridge, Hanging Bridge, Flying Fox ), Rafting Bandung ( Palayangan Pangalengan, Cikandang Garut, Citarik Sukabumi), Amazing Race, Paintball, Airsoft Gun, Fun Off Road, ATV, Paralayang, Joyflight With Trike Tandem.
Iklan Bandung 168
Men Cars
Asyik Ngeblog
Cus Ngeblog
Asuransi Prudential Bandung merupakan istilah yang digunakan dalam merujuk pada tindakan, sistem, atau bisnis di mana perlindungan finansial atau ganti rugi secara finansial untuk jiwa, properti, kesehatan, Pendidikan, jiwa dan lain sebagainya untuk mendapatkan penggantian dari kejadian-kejadian tak terduga yang dapat terjadi seperti kematian, kehilangan, kerusakan atau sakit, namun kita harus melakukan pembayaran premi secara teratur pada Agen Prudential Bandung dalam jangka waktu tertentu sebagai pengganti polis yang menjamin perlindungan tersebut. Asurasi Prudential Bandung memberikan perlindungan untuk hidup yang lebih aman dan terjamin. Pelayanan Asuransi kesehatan prudential Bandung adalah kebutuhan bagi setiap orang.

Kota Bandung yang merupakan ibukota Provinsi Jawa Barat yang terkenal dengan kesejukannya, Bandung Tour menjadi destinasi favorit bagi wisatawan domestik maupun mancanegara yang wajib menjadi agenda Tour Bandung. Bandung Tour Package
Tuesday, January 15th 2019 @ 8:27 AM

Posted by slither io:

Your article is very good, I have read a lot of articles but I am really impressed with your article. Thank you, I will review this article. To know about me, try talking to me
Friday, December 28th 2018 @ 11:09 PM

Posted by hansara911:

Text is very sharp and deep, I was impressed by you. Thank you
instagram web app
instagram video size
Monday, November 26th 2018 @ 7:57 PM

Posted by aditus:

Dollar General is conducting the survey because of increased competition, companies are enhancing guest dgcustomerfirst com satisfaction and keeping their existing guests
Friday, November 9th 2018 @ 5:13 AM

Posted by Joy:

Posted by gilbran:

Good information, thank u and please visit back my article~!
obat sakit tumit di apotik
Thursday, September 6th 2018 @ 12:52 AM

Posted by Taylor Shaw:

So good to see so much details regarding Bassoon Reed Making here. The preparation of profiled cane for forming is a hard job and the various ways to achieve it has been explained in detail through the blog. Do share more updates. seo training ernakulam
Saturday, April 21st 2018 @ 2:13 AM

Posted by lagu31:

I really like your writing ,, very detail and nice to understand:):):)
Wednesday, March 14th 2018 @ 4:42 AM

Posted by kamsss8:

good post found here. site
Wednesday, February 21st 2018 @ 4:56 AM

Posted by kursus kendal:

mantap gan, kepoin yuk!!!

kursus komputer desain kendal
Sunday, December 17th 2017 @ 3:34 AM

Posted by MSS Consulting:

Posted by harga izumio s lutena:

Posted by Horoskop hari ini:

Very interesting
Sunday, February 5th 2017 @ 5:43 PM

Posted by Obat Sipilis:

Hello very nice website!! Guy , .. Excellent .. Super..
I will bookmark your site and take the feeds also?
I am glad to search out a lot of useful info here
in the post, we’d like work out more strategies on this
regard, thank you for sharing Obat Sipilis
Monday, May 9th 2016 @ 12:22 AM

Posted by Website Jelly Gamat:

Posted by Obat Jelly Gamat:

Posted by Kumpulan PIN BBM:

This article and many other on your blog are very interesting.
I'm very interested in learning more about your site.
Do you have a fanspage on facebook or other.?

Kumpulan PIN BBM
Monday, February 29th 2016 @ 2:42 AM

Posted by Birthday Card Ideas:

I am very pleased to visit your website, how amazed I am with you because it has been willing to share information that is very interesting and certainly useful for me. I will never be bored for a visit and will always be happy to see your collection. thank you, I really like.

Birthday Card Ideas
1st Birthday Invitation Wording
Pictures of Birthday Cards
Harry Potter Birthday Invitations
Create Your Own Birthday Invitations
Kids Birthday Invitation Wording
Sunday, February 28th 2016 @ 11:33 AM

Post New Comment

No Smilies More Smilies »